2011 fantasy baseball relief pitchers: National League bullpen situations, setup men and holds

Holds are one of the most difficult fantasy baseball statistics to predict. But we’re going to try anyway.

If you’re searching for holds, you’ve likely already found our 2010 holds leaders and our AL bullpen situations and setup men. Now let’s look at the National League.

Really, the league has the cream of the crop when it comes to setup men and we only have to look at one team to prove it.

The team in question, obvious to any seasoned holds-league veteran, is the San Diego Padres. They had three players score at least 10 holds, and two of them had 38 or more. That is not a typo.

The two numbers accompanying these National League bullpen reports are total holds (from all players with 10 or more) and the average holds per reliever in the sample. Check out the AL discussion for a more detailed explanation of the ranking.

The teams are ranked based on average. This represents teams, managers or situations that lend themselves to high individual holds totals.

Let’s take a look at some of the most notable bullpens in the National League:

San Diego Padres

Holds average: 29.7 | Total: 89

Closer: Heath Bell

We’re starting in San Diego because they managed both of last year’s top setup men in Luke Gregerson (MLB-leading 40) and Mike Adams (38). Until further notice, they are our benchmarks for great setup men.

Cincinnatti Reds

Holds average: 23 | Total: 46

Closer: Francisco Cordero

We have to highlight the Reds this early because of Aroldis Chapman. Francisco Cordero is a time bomb waiting to go off. Chapman will be the closer. He should give you well above average Ks and until he gets the closer role, he should get a pile of holds. Arthur Rhodes moved on to the Rangers so Nick Masset is the next in line for holds.

Colorado Rockies

Holds average: 21.3 | Total: 64

Closer: Huston Street

The Rockies boasted three players with 20 or more holds in 2010. Rafael Betancourt and Matt Belisle were more effective than Joe Beimel, who took a job with the Pirates in the offseason. That means either Franklin Morales or Matt Lindstrom get those additional statistics or Betancourt and Belisle get to pad their totals.

Atlanta Braves

Holds average: 20.7 | Total: 62

Closer: Craig Kimbrel

Jonny Venters looks to go from fireballing closer to fireballing setup man. He’ll post 100 Ks and 30 holds. If Craig Kimbrel falters, he’ll get some save opportunities. Pete Moylan could come away with a couple holds, but he’ll spend a lot of time on your waiver wire as well.

Los Angeles Dodgers

Holds average: 18.5 | Total: 37

Closer: Jonathan Broxton

Hong-Chih Kuo was on several of my teams last year. He notched 21 holds, 12 saves and matched sterling ratios with more than a K per inning. That made him, arguably, the best non-closing reliever in fantasy last season. However, the pen is deep behind closer Jonathan Broxton. Kenley Jansen, LA’s closer in waiting, and new addition Matt Guerrier, who held 21 for the Twins last season, will both be in the mix. Hard to punt Kuo because an excellent pitcher is going to get his opportunities. Still the logjam is a bit worrisome.

Washington Nationals

Holds average: 17.7 | Total: 53

Closer: Drew Storen/Sean Burnett

The first name that should spring to any holds-league player’s mind when they think Nationals is Tyler Clippard. Clippard had a truly impressive fantasy season, with 11 wins, 23 holds, a save and 112 strikeouts in 91 innings. He, however, also blew 10 saves, lost 8 games, walked 41 batters and allowed 110 baserunners in 91 innings. Don’t overbid. His teammate, Sean Burnett, doesn’t strike out as many, but had as many holds and better ratios in 2010. He’ll split closing duties with Drew Storen in 2011.

Florida Marlins

Holds average: 17.7 | Total: 53

Closer: Leo Nunez

A couple Florida players will earn holds, but the one we need to focus on most is Clay Hensley. Hensley improved dramatically last season. He improved so much I’ve read some rumormongers pointing to Hensley unseating Leo Nunez at closer before the season is over. When you’re targeting setup men in any format, the guy in line for saves, but who will get some holds, should always be among the top targets.

Milwaukee Brewers

Holds average: 16 | Total: 64

Closer: John Axford

If I could flat out tell you that Kameron Loe was the dude in the eighth, I’d do that. But I have my doubts. Call Takashi Saito, LaTroy Hawkins and Zack Braddock our monkeywrenches. It’s not that I don’t like the other guys, it’s that Loe’s second half last year was so promising. Still, Saito’s probably in line for holds. Hawkins is a liability, but for some reason the depth chart always has him right under the closer. Braddock was impressive in a second half that doesn’t fit with his skill (lucky!). Still his K/9 is exciting and at 23, he could make the proper adjustments to be a force in the bullpen. Draft any of them? Yep, well, except Hawkins. Saito and Hawkins are both old as dirt, but Hawkins has had some trouble playing baseball the last couple years.

Pittsburgh

Holds average: 14.7 | Total: 44

Closer: Joel Hanrahan

Evan Meek and Joel Hanrahan each had significant holds totals in 2010. This year, Hanrahan is coming out in the ninth and will replace Meek just about every time. Opponents hit just .185 against Meek last season, expect him to get a bigger workload in 2011.

Likely holds leaders for the next teams on the list:

Houston: Wilton Lopez

San Francisco: Sergio Romo

Philadelphia: Ryan Madson

St. Louis: Jason Motte

5 Responses to “2011 fantasy baseball relief pitchers: National League bullpen situations, setup men and holds”


  1. CJones

    Great to see the holds update – Kuo is my only NL setup man for now, looking forward to your projections for AL.

    Which Rockies RP would you go with for holds at this point – Belisle or Betancourt?

  2. ep

    Belisle is five years younger but 2010 was his best season by a significant margin. It’s unlikely he’ll reproduce it.

    He’ll give up home runs, but Betancourt had 89 Ks and only 8 walks last season. That’s some pretty good command.

  3. Ryan

    Still no respect for the Giants. None at the beginning of the playoffs, none throughout the playoffs, and still none after they take home the championship.

    Sergio Romo 2010: 2.18 ERA, 0.97 WHIP, .204 AVG against, 46 holds
    Sergio Romo 2011 thus far: 1.83 ERA, 0.67 WHIP, .160 AVG against

    The guy is unreal. Recognize.

  4. ep

    Ryan,
    Thanks for the comment, but Romo only had 21 holds last year.
    And the next player on the team, Santiago Casilla, had only 11.

    San Fran’s bullpen had only 65 holds total last year. The Padres top three setup relievers had 89, the Rockies top three had 64 and the Braves top three had 62. The Brewers top four had 64.

    Romo’s excellent, but based on last year, he was the only Giant setup man worth owning. That’s why he is listed but the bullpen isn’t discussed in any detail.

  5. five mistakes

    Your blog is pretty cool to me and your subject matter is very relevant. I was browsing around and came across something you might find interesting. I was guilty of 3 of them with my sites. “99% of site owners are committing these five HUGE errors”. http://bit.ly/uEMWS2 You will be suprised how simple they are to fix.